University_XP_YT_Banner_2048x1152 copy.jpg

Podcast

Experience Points

Episode 177 AP Table Talk: I Cut, You Choose

AP Table Talk: I Cut, You Choose

Episode Summary:

In this episode of AP Table Talk, Brian and Dave split the I cut, you choose mechanic, where one player divides a set of resources into groups and another player gets first pick. Starting from the childhood ritual of one sibling cutting and the other choosing, they trace the mechanic from the pie rule in abstract classics like Hex to modern standouts like New York Slice, The Great Split, Agent Avenue, Pacific Ocean, Castles of Mad King Ludwig, and Isle of Skye. They make the case for I cut, you choose as a self-balancing decision structure that hands authorship of each choice to the players and keeps both the splitter and the chooser engaged, then weigh its pitfalls - analysis paralysis for the splitter, choices that can feel like guesses under hidden information, kingmaking from a careless split, and games like Ponte del Diavolo and Hanamikoji where the mechanic only appears in a corner of the design. In the bonus round, Dave runs the mechanic through a set of definitional tests using Honeypot, Brian asks whether the splitter or the chooser holds the inherent advantage, and they rule out Captain Flip and Tiny Towns as edge cases.

(0:13 - 1:26)

Brian Eng:

Hello and welcome to AP Table Talk, a podcast where we explore board games and what makes them interesting to us. As always, I'm your host, Brian, and splitting this episode with me today, my co-host, Dave Eng.

Dave Eng:

I see what you did there, Bri. I will choose the better portion of the episode. So, our... yeah, our episode today, we'll be discussing the I cut, you choose mechanic.

Brian Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Dave Eng:

I cut, you choose. So, the I cut, you choose mechanic. If you've not listened to AP Table Talk before, Brian usually does his shoot-from-the-hip, off-the-cuff definition of I cut, you choose, and then I'll read the one off BGG. So, Brian, you want to do yours?

Brian Eng:

Sure. So, another one that I think is pretty self-defining, and I think a lot of people get introduced to this mechanic in their childhood. And it essentially boils down to exactly what it says. One player creates two options, the split, and then the other player gets to choose first which option they want. And that group could be groups of resources, or ability cards, or whatever it is, sometimes a combination. And they basically try to split it up however they want, but the other person gets to pick first.

(1:27 - 2:19)

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah. And then you said childhood, Bri, because I'm assuming you mean what I think we're both thinking about right now. It's like two kids have got to split, like, a pizza. One person is going to make the cut, and then the other person gets to choose which side of the pizza.

Brian Eng:

Exactly, the classic origin. And actually, it's funny, because I don't know if this is just, like, adolescent egocentrism or whatever, but it's one of those things where I thought that me and my brother Chris invented this when I was little. Because my brother used to cut up fruit for us as a snack when I was little, you know, and I would always get this small, tiny piece.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And then I used to get upset, and one day he was like, okay, he'll cut it and then I'll get to choose which one.

(2:20 - 3:54)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

And I just thought, "Oh my gosh, that's amazing." I thought we created that, but obviously it has been around for a long time.

Dave Eng:

I mean, it's kind of genius, right?

Brian Eng:

Yeah, it's a self-balancing thing.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, like as part of the decision family, right?

Brian Eng:

And I mean, obviously we'll get into that, I guess, as we discuss some more.

Dave Eng:

Right.

Brian Eng:

All right.

Dave Eng:

You want me to run through that?

Brian Eng:

Oh, yeah. The official, right?

Dave Eng:

Okay. So, the definition of I cut, you choose that does not involve your sibling is, quote, "A method of drafting where one player divides a set of resources into different groups; other players have first choice of which group to select. This mechanism can also be used to divide more abstract resources, like turn order. Many games use the so-called 'pie rule' or 'swap rule' to minimize first player advantage, e.g. Hex. In this game, the first player makes the first move of the game, and then the second player can choose to switch sides (taking over the first player's color as well as that first move), or to let the first player stay with that color and first move, and the second player then makes their first move in response to the first player's move. After that, turns continue as usual."

So, to your point, Brian, again, splitting things. This one talked about the Hex pie rule, which I think I brought up last episode. I did not realize it's called the pie rule, but again, it's self-balancing, right?

(3:55 - 4:40)

Brian Eng:

Right. Yes. Yes. And I mean, the pie rule is a good name, because the example of, I guess, a more recent game that kind of boils down to the pure form of the rule is a game that you introduced me to, which is New York Slice.

Dave Eng:

Yep. Yep.

Brian Eng:

Which is essentially... the game is a pizza, and there's pieces that are different slices of pizza with different toppings on them, and one person has to divide up the slices into groups, and then I guess the other players pick.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, and the person who divides gets whatever is left over.

Brian Eng:

That's exactly where the whole pie rule name comes from.

Dave Eng:

It's like the quintessential game to explain this, right?

(4:41 - 5:51)

Brian Eng:

Hopefully. Well, it's not going to be the only game we talk about, but that definitely, to me, is very literally the mechanic. It's like worker placement, the worker placement...

Dave Eng:

Oh, no. You're building... the deck building game.

Brian Eng:

Deck building. Yeah.

Dave Eng:

Okay, so that's the definition. We should make a deck building game, the Deck Building game, but you're building, like, a backyard deck.

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

But it doesn't involve deck building.

Brian Eng:

And there's no deck building.

Dave Eng:

No, no, no. You misread it. It's not that kind of...

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Dave Eng:

This is a push-your-luck game.

Brian Eng:

All right, so we move on to our major examples, then?

Dave Eng:

Yeah, major examples. Okay. So, if you're listening to AP Table Talk for the first time, in this next section we're going to go over major examples. Brian and I are going to be talking about our first, our favorite, and our most noteworthy games that use this mechanic. The way we do this is we both have d20s, and we're going to roll them right now, and whoever rolls highest is going to lead. So, Brian, my die is ready. Your die?

(5:52 - 7:37)

Brian Eng:

I'm ready.

Dave Eng:

Excellent. All right, ready to roll in three, two, one, go.

Brian Eng:

Oh. Natural 20.

Dave Eng:

Oh, I got nine. Okay.

Brian Eng:

Okay. So, well, when we were doing the definitions, I specifically tried not to look at the BGG definition so that I could pull it with my own.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Which, in this case, is a little unfortunate. So, we were discussing a little before, and this is specifically this first game played. I had a little trouble, because, again, this mechanic has been around for a long time, but I was having trouble determining a game that kind of specifically used it.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

So, I kind of just put general games that use the pie rule.

Dave Eng:

Okay.

Brian Eng:

And I did put Hex in here, you know, because that is one of the earliest games I could think of that uses it. I believe that some people use it in Go as well. But yeah, so I did use Hex, which I know we mentioned briefly. Basically, it's an old two-player abstract game. It's a board of hex spaces where each player has the two opposite ends of the... I'm sorry, of a... what is it, like a rhombus, I guess, of hexes. And you're trying to take spaces and create an unbroken chain from one end to the other. And the player that plays first picks their first turn, and then the second player can choose to either take that turn as their first turn and give the second turn to the other player, or they can continue on and allow that person to keep it. So, the split being, do you want first player advantage, or do you want this position?

(7:38 - 8:28)

Because I do think that game, without that, has this pretty significant first player advantage.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And I think that the mechanic helps balance it out.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

I think that's almost a primary reason for its development and why the pie rule kind of exists.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Old, old abstract game. But yeah, I couldn't really think of a specific one that I played first that used it, because I almost feel like we would just add it in if we thought a game had a first-player advantage. We could just add the rule.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah. I wonder, though, when you say add that in, right, are you talking about, like, when you're playing with Chris?

Brian Eng:

Yeah, we'd just... I mean, the other thing that people do, in games like chess, you just play two games and you swap first player, right?

(8:29 - 9:17)

Dave Eng:

Right, right, right. But I'm also thinking, as a kid, I would assume going first is always great. But then, as we've learned, going first in a trick-taking game, usually not, right?

Brian Eng:

Right, right, right. But going first in a worker placement game, usually very good.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And yeah, there's various ways that they try to balance that. A lot of worker placements use resources, like, the earlier you go, the fewer resources you start with.

Dave Eng:

Oh, yeah.

Brian Eng:

That kind of thing. Which, I think that works out better in a worker placement than trying to do a pie rule in a worker placement. But yeah, I mean, I guess it could still work.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, you know, I've never seen that in a worker placement. The pie rule is, like, I think, exclusively two-player games, right?

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I guess it would be hard to do it with more than two players.

(9:18 - 10:16)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

Specifically, the pie rule. But anyways, yeah, so I guess I put Hex down, but I didn't really have a specific first game played that I could think of that was at least older.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

My favorite could fall in there, but it's definitely from when I was already into modern board games.

Dave Eng:

Okay. So, should I go on?

Brian Eng:

Yeah, why don't you go ahead and do your first, and maybe it'll trigger some memories.

Dave Eng:

Well, you brought it up right during the explanation, and I think mine is New York Slice.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

Because actually, when I looked up the history for this game, I think New York Slice was originally developed as just a game called Piece o' Cake, and it was, like, literal dessert pies.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

And I think Bézier acquired the license to retheme it, and they made it New York Slice. Which, I will say, they did a great job with the theme. It's very awesome. Like, we just played it yesterday with Banditos, and the box is shaped like a pizza box.

(10:17 - 11:06)

Brian Eng:

The box is a pizza.

Dave Eng:

But it is perfectly themed, and components-wise, it's great.

Brian Eng:

It's a very light game.

Dave Eng:

Yes, very light, but they did a great job with the theming and production of it. I also want to say, Brian and I, we are not official spokespeople for Bézier, but I want to just tell everyone about this for the theme, because I think it deserves recognition. One, the box is shaped like a pizza box. Two, the rulebook looks like a menu.

Brian Eng:

Oh, yeah.

Dave Eng:

Three, the scorepad looks like a guest check, like the bill.

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

And then all the pizza slices that you select are chipboard, like thick cardboard, shaped like a pizza. And then they have some additional components in it, like a daily special, which is like a rule change to the game that you add as part of the division for New York Slice, if I remember correctly.

(11:07 - 12:25)

Brian Eng:

It's fairly thick chipboard for the pizza slices.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, it's good, good quality components.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, like, whoever was like, "Let's make this the theme," really did their homework here. It's just like, let's make all of it theme, you know?

Dave Eng:

But I originally got this game on closeout because of the theme. I thought it was just, you know, a really light game with a really great theme. Overall, even the decision seems like it is thematic, right? Because you're taking this whole pizza, and you're dividing it up for the people in the group, because they're going to choose it.

Although, I think I experienced this yesterday, some analysis paralysis in choosing the slices, because, for those that haven't played, the slices are all different. They're numbered, and each number represents a different type of pizza, and part of the scoring at the end is developing majorities. So, there's, like, pepperoni pizza, I think there's 11 slices in the deck, and it gets you 11 points, I think, but it's hard to get majority because there's so many slices available. Whereas the other pieces that have fewer slices, it's easier to get majority, but it's not worth as many points.

But overall, I think that is my first, because I really struggled with this, Bri, the first game I played that featured I split, you choose. And I also have a runner-up, right? Did you have a runner-up?

(12:26 - 13:22)

Brian Eng:

I don't for the first game played, because I could barely think of one game. But I do have one for my favorite, but we'll get to that in the next section.

Dave Eng:

Okay, can I bring up mine? So, one of the things I discovered when playing New York Slice is, one, I got the analysis paralysis, which is bad. Another game that I own that I got on closeout is a game called Skyward. It's like a tableau-building game where you're building a colony in the sky. It was very much, like, airships, blimps, flying-based. But these resources come up and then you split them, and you're supposed to split them the New York Slice way, where you draw a bunch and then you... I think they call it the Marshal... you break them up. But when I played it, I was like, whoever's the Marshal just takes forever, because they're looking at everything. They're looking at your tableau. They're like, "Okay, I don't want them to have this. I've got to do that."

(13:23 - 14:09)

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

So, here's a house rule that I came up with, Brian. I'm sharing it because you said originally you and Chris did the house rule for the pie swap. My house rule is that instead of the Marshal taking all eight cards and then splitting them, the Marshal draws them one at a time and then assigns them to a lot.

Brian Eng:

Okay. So, they don't have perfect information, then.

Dave Eng:

Correct.

Brian Eng:

They have to go off of each item, which... yeah, that'll speed things up a little bit.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. And, like, it's probably not great from a strategy standpoint, but from a "you're taking forever, bro" kind of standpoint, right? It worked much better. So, my runner-up is Skyward. Not the first game, but I was thinking about analysis paralysis with New York Slice, and I thought about my change for that.

(14:10 - 15:01)

Brian Eng:

Okay. Yeah. Well, if we're moving on to favorites...

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah, go ahead.

Brian Eng:

I have kind of two options here. So, I have an earlier one in my modern board gaming, and then I have a more modern one. And my earlier one, it's probably my earliest one where it's a significant mechanic of the game.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And also, speaking of analysis paralysis, I played this game many, many times with my wife.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

We really like it. But, as I've probably mentioned in previous episodes, she is very prone to analysis paralysis.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

So, this is definitely a game where I would just do something else on her turn, and we've played it a few times now. And it's Castles of Mad King Ludwig.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

Now, even at two players, you can get analysis paralysis. At more than that, it's even worse. So, in this game, it's a tile-laying, kind of set collection game.

(15:02 - 15:52)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And you are building castles room by room, and the rooms have unique shapes and sizes and categories, and they each have to connect by doorways, and it's kind of random where the doorways are on the rooms, and you earn points by how they're placed in your castle. So, you're each building a castle, and you get points for completing rooms, which means that every door is connected to something, or rooms have specific goals, like, oh, this room gets bonuses if it's beside bedrooms or hallways or something like that.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And then you also have some hidden personal goals, so, like, if you have the most small square rooms, you get bonus points, things like that. And then on each turn, there's an active player, and they draw room tiles, and then they arrange them along a pricing board, and there's fixed prices ranging from 1,000 to 15,000 gold.

(15:53 - 16:47)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And then, in turn order, the other players each purchase one of the rooms, but instead of paying the bank, all the money that they use to purchase the room goes to the active player. And then the active player buys last, and that money goes to the bank.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm. Okay.

Brian Eng:

But because of all the moving parts with all the rooms, and if you have multiple players, looking at each other's castles and what they need, trying to price all the rooms and where you want to put them on the board... yeah, it's one where the analysis paralysis is understandable.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

And even when we played a few games on Board Game Arena, it just got to a point where it was like, "This is good enough. I'm just going to hit go." But yes, I really like that game. Now, it kind of strays slightly from the I cut, you choose. I guess you'd call it "I price, you buy."

(16:48 - 17:35)

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah. But I think it's essentially the I split, you choose for more than two players.

Brian Eng:

Right, right. And you're splitting... you're splitting a price, basically splitting the rooms into price categories.

Dave Eng:

Uh-huh.

Brian Eng:

But then you become the last to choose. So, if you put a room very cheap so that it doesn't cost you a lot of money, someone else might buy it first, and then it won't be there for you. Or if you know, oh, that person wants this room, I want them to buy it because I want the money from it...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

But if I put it too high, then they won't buy it anymore, right? Or if you really don't want them to have it... the amount of money you have is not secret in that game, so you can just price it so they can't buy it.

(17:36 - 18:34)

Dave Eng:

Which, the cash starvation method is my fear. Yeah, you know, I noticed that when we were playing on Board Game Arena. At first I was like, "Ah, I won't watch a video. I'll just see if I can play it." And I was like, "Why am I broke constantly? Oh, I need money." There's a solution where I can just get money?

Brian Eng:

Yes. And it is possible that you can't buy something in a round, so you can just take, I think, 5,000 gold or something, but then you don't get a room. So, you're one room behind everyone else.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

And that is part of what I enjoy in that game. But yeah, again, that whole psychological valuation of how you think people value the rooms and stuff, I like that in that game, right? So, that was my first... That may have been my first modern game, because I don't think I got it right when it came out. That game was 2014, but it was definitely around that time, so maybe 2015.

(18:35 - 19:44)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

So, that would have been fairly early in the modern renaissance, if you know what I mean. All right. So, yeah, that I have as my favorite. And did you have kind of a tie? Do you want me to do my second one, or do you want to do yours? Do you have a runner-up in this one as well?

Dave Eng:

Yeah, I have two runners-up. What is best here? You want to do...

Brian Eng:

Why don't you do your favorite, and then we'll come back to me. I'll do a runner-up, and you can do your runner-up.

Dave Eng:

Okay, cool. So, my favorite is, and we've been playing this a lot on Board Game Arena, The Great Split.

Brian Eng:

I will say, I did enjoy that one.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, it's a good one, because I think if New York Slice is really thematic and also an appropriate use of this mechanic, I would say this is just the overall cleanest with multiple players, because it's literally just taking a hand of cards, and you're splitting it, and you're giving it to either the person on your left or your right, and then they are going to take one of the two options, and whatever option they don't choose comes back to you.

(19:45 - 20:34)

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

And if listeners haven't played The Great Split before, it's very much a track-focused game, where with the cards you get back, you go up on certain tracks. Those tracks give you money, and whoever's furthest up on certain tracks compared to other players gets more points. So, yeah, I think that The Great Split is the game that does it the cleanest for multiple players, you know.

Brian Eng:

So, I have a question for you, because we've only played it on Board Game Arena between the two of us.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

When you have, let's say we had three players...

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

...are you splitting your cards into three different groups, or are you just passing to only one person?

Dave Eng:

Yeah, you only pass to one person.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

You put the split cards in the middle, and then you either pass that to the person on your left or right.

(20:35 - 21:22)

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

And then you get an envelope from another player, right?

Brian Eng:

Right, right. So, when you're deciding on your split, you only need to look at yours and the person you're passing to, not everyone else.

Dave Eng:

Correct. Yeah.

Brian Eng:

I will say, I'm going to cut in, and I'll let you get back to it in a second here, but the thing that I think is unique in that game that I enjoy is that it is a simultaneous I split, you choose.

Dave Eng:

Yes.

Brian Eng:

You're both doing it. So, the problem with Castles of Mad King Ludwig, or the other games that have the analysis paralysis, is that downtime when the person is deciding how to split the thing, and it became long. Castles, for us...

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

So, in this one, because you're both splitting at the same time, it kind of mitigates that a little bit.

(21:23 - 22:16)

Dave Eng:

Yeah, and I found that interesting. Do you have The Great Split, Brian? Do you own it?

Brian Eng:

I do not. That was my first time playing it, with you on Board Game Arena.

Dave Eng:

Oh, I see. Because I think that you and Violet would like that, because it works well between two.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I was just going to say, I'm curious as to how it does with more, because it seems really good at two players.

Dave Eng:

Yep. Yeah, and I do think the I split, you choose mechanic ideally is good at two players. But we can get into that in the later segments. I have two runners-up, but before I do that, I'll throw it back to you for your runner-up.

Brian Eng:

Sure. Yeah, so a more modern one that I recently discovered, and I thought that I wouldn't like it, but then I got really into it, and I had to go find it and bought it, was Agent Avenue.

(22:17 - 23:20)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

So, that is a two-player card game, and you essentially have your spies, and you're chasing each other around a circular track. You each start on opposite ends, and you're moving spaces backwards or forwards, trying to catch the other spy.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

There's some set collection, but it's essentially I split, you choose and bluffing, the game. You have a hand of four cards, and on each turn, you're going to take two of those cards, and you're going to put one face down and one face up, and the other player gets to choose one.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

So, it's the "what's in the box?" You can have this card or the one that's upside down, you know, which is where the bluffing comes in.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And whichever one they don't choose, the active player gets back for themselves, and then it goes into set collection. There's different types of cards, and the more you have of each type, they kind of get more powerful. And some cards are like, if you get three of them, you win the game, and if you get three of them, you instantly lose the game.

(23:21 - 24:10)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Those kinds of things. But yeah, the whole game is essentially just, okay, here's two cards, one where you know what it is and one where you don't, and you pick one, right? And it's very simple, but it moves so quick, and it's such a quick game. Like, my kids can play it and it's still fun. And again, it's one of those things where, because it comes down to playing mind games with the other person...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

...I really enjoy it. And I mean, there is the calculated risk of the cards you're going to put down, like, what if I get stuck with the one I didn't want?

Dave Eng:

Yep.

Brian Eng:

Those kinds of things which I enjoy. And I think there's one expansion that I have, which adds a second player piece that can do things on the board, and then there is supposedly another expansion coming.

(24:11 - 25:05)

Dave Eng:

Okay. Do you have the Black-Market expansion too, or does the Black-Market come in the box?

Brian Eng:

That is... So, the simple game is without it.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

But I would consider the Black-Market game to be the standard game.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah. It's good for learning without it, but it gets much more interesting with the Black-Market.

Brian Eng:

I agree. Yeah, because there's cards which normally would be considered a penalty, of going backwards.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

But with the Black-Market, there are four spaces on the board where, if you land on them, you get to take a power, a card from the Black-Market. And it's a good way... I talked about that calculated risk. Well, you can put down a penalty card, because you know that if you end up with it, it's a minus one, but it'll land you on the Black-Market, so you'll at least get a Black-Market card. So, it adds some layers to the game.

(25:06 - 25:50)

Dave Eng:

All right, right.

Brian Eng:

But yeah, I really enjoy that game. And yeah, again, at this stage, I like simple games that I don't get bored of, too, because I can play them with my kids over and over again and not lose my mind.

Dave Eng:

Right.

Brian Eng:

So, that is my runner-up for favorite.

Dave Eng:

Well, your runner-up is my runner-up, because I'm trying to divide it like this, Bri. I think New York Slice is the most thematic implementation of this mechanic.

Brian Eng:

Yes, the most literal adaptation.

Dave Eng:

You know, literally, like, this pizza pie. All right. The Great Split is what I'd call the cleanest multiplayer implementation, and I think Agent Avenue is the cleanest two-player implementation of it, right?

(25:51 - 26:50)

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Of resources, not turns, like Hex. Yeah, definitely, it is a very bare-bones I split, you choose game.

Dave Eng:

Correct. Yeah. But my other runner-up, though, is another game I had backed on Kickstarter. It's a small mint tin game called Pacific Ocean.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

And it is like Agent Avenue, only the two cards, I believe, are both face up.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

You're trying to build a tableau, you're doing set collection, and depending on what your specific goals are, the cards' values are kind of asymmetric. So, I guess unlike Agent Avenue, where, if you've played Agent Avenue before, I think it's the Daredevil, if you get three of them, you lose the game instantly, Pacific Ocean is much more about collecting icons, set collection, and everything else like that. But I would say that you're not going to get a cleaner implementation of this mechanic that I've seen besides The Great Split and Agent Avenue.

(26:51 - 27:43)

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I have not played that Pacific Ocean game, but it sounds similar. But yeah, there's something about that twist, that one of the cards is face down.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

I enjoy that imperfect information.

Dave Eng:

Yes. Yes.

Brian Eng:

Okay, so that is our favorites. Going to go into most noteworthy.

Dave Eng:

Yep, and then you get to lead, right?

Brian Eng:

Okay. So, for this one, it is another kind of older modern game, and it is Isle of Skye.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

You played that one?

Dave Eng:

Yes, I have, several times.

Brian Eng:

So, when I explain it to people, I kind of call it almost like solitaire Carcassonne. It's similar tile placing to Carcassonne, where you're placing these square tiles with roads and different things on them, and you're kind of building these territories, but you each have your own personal island that you're building.

(27:44 - 29:00)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And each round, players draw terrain tiles and kind of purchase or sell tiles, and I'll get into that, and then points are awarded based on random scoring objectives that change round to round, and that's the kind of variability for the game.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

But instead of just normal tile drafting, what you do is each player draws three tiles, and then, of those three, you have a little screen. Behind the screen, you are going to place an axe on one, and that tile will be discarded, and then you will price the other two tiles. But the way you price the tiles is you put your own money on them, your own coins. So, if I say, okay, this one's going to be one, you have to put one of your own coins on it, and if the other one's going to be three, you have to put three of your own coins on it. Then, once everybody's ready, everybody reveals, and then, in turn order, each player can buy one tile from any opponent if they want. Any of the remaining tiles that weren't purchased get purchased with whatever coins were left on them.

(29:01 - 29:50)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And again, it kind of has that simultaneous splitting going on, which cuts back on that AP. But it's just interesting, because your coins are your purchasing power, but also your ability to price the tiles.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Which I found really... it's this kind of really tight, like, catch-22 kind of economics.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Because if you want to keep a tile that you need, you have to set a really high price, but then you're going to be paying that price, because no matter what... the only way that you're not going to have to spend those coins is if someone buys it, right? But then you're not getting the tile. So, if you set it high enough, I guess you'll get enough coins to hopefully make it worth it.

(29:51 - 30:36)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

And yeah, I really like that kind of risk-reward tension.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And I guess, in a way, it kind of resolves some of that punishing feeling if somebody does take what you want, because as long as you price it high enough, well, you're going to get a bunch of coins.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, right.

Brian Eng:

So, and I do think that it solves the I split, you choose scaling better than Castles.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

Because of the simultaneous pricing, right? But yeah, I really enjoyed that one. I think it won Spiel... actually, I think that's why I put it in most noteworthy.

Dave Eng:

Isle of Skye?

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I think it did, because that's the list I used to use to buy games for my brother.

(30:37 - 31:23)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

It's like, oh, it's a Spiel game, so he'll probably like it.

Dave Eng:

Let's see. I have to know now. Yeah, see, it won 2016.

Brian Eng:

2016, yes.

Dave Eng:

Okay. Kennerspiel.

Brian Eng:

So, hobby.

Dave Eng:

Yes. Yes. Obviously. Oh, so it was, um... it was 10 years ago now. Oh, I think Pfister co-designed this.

Brian Eng:

I did not know that.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, I couldn't remember who it was off the bat, but Alexander Pfister. He did Oh My Goods!, that we played recently, and Great Western Trail, right?

Brian Eng:

Great Western Trail, Port Royal, Mombasa. Sorry, a tangent here: I picked up, I think it's Pirates of Maracaibo.

Dave Eng:

Yep, that's Alexander Pfister.

Brian Eng:

I got it in the bargain bin at my game store.

Dave Eng:

Oh, nice.

Brian Eng:

I was like, oh, I think my daughter is getting to where she could play that one.

(31:24 - 32:08)

Dave Eng:

That's good.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, because I think that's the simpler of those games, right? Than the other Maracaibo game.

Dave Eng:

You know, your daughters, when you teach them this early and then they start playing with their friends, they're totally going to crush their friends at games.

Brian Eng:

I remember that. That's basically me and Chris, my brother, as well. Like, yeah, I would learn all these strategies early. Chris would destroy me, but when I played anyone else, I was so far ahead.

Dave Eng:

Well, this is when... um, I think Chris told me that his daughter Lily and her boyfriend Ray would play Jaipur together, and Lily would just crush him constantly, to the point where she was getting bored. She's like, "You want to play?" Right? And he's like, "Yeah, I have to win."

(32:09 - 32:57)

Brian Eng:

Oh, you'll play for a long time.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, so she just kept repeatedly crushing him. But yeah, she picked up games early too, because she was playing Catan fairly young.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I think it's a family thing.

Dave Eng:

All right. Yeah, I mean, it's ingrained. We're always playing games. The kids are going to grow up playing games.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. All right, so I'll ask, what was your most noteworthy? That was my most noteworthy.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Okay, so I have my selected response, and I have my runner-up. We've both talked about these games already, so I'm not going to rehash what we talked about. My runner-up was Isle of Skye.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

And I agree with you. I think that this does a much better job compared to Castles of Mad King Ludwig at the AP, and at being able to address a larger player count, right?

(32:58 - 33:48)

Brian Eng:

And actually, sorry, just to go back to Castles for a second. One of the reasons why it's my favorite... and we've talked about another game that is often compared to Castles of Mad King Ludwig, which is Suburbia.

Dave Eng:

Oh, yeah. I forgot about that.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. And most people, I think, agree that Suburbia is the better game.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

But I just really like the theme of Castles of Mad King Ludwig. I like that the rooms and hallways are different shapes and sizes, and when you're done, you've built something.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

And in fact, in the standard game for two players, I can't remember what the room count is, but essentially the game goes until you run out of rooms, and there's a specific number of rooms per player count.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

And Violet and I, what we like is building. So, we just played with, like, double the rooms.

(33:49 - 34:35)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And we just kept the game going, because we just want these big castles. You can't see what our castles look like after. And honestly, that was a big appeal. I mean, theme plays a big part in the appeal of games for me, and that's one of the main reasons I really enjoy that one, building out the castle and then seeing these weird things, like, why does this room have five hallways attached to it?

Dave Eng:

Exactly. Yeah.

Brian Eng:

So, with any of the other games, I don't feel like the theme came through as strong. Or, sorry, it's not even that the theme didn't come through strong, but just the look of these different shaped rooms and stuff, right? I just really like that when the game is done, you look at the castle you built.

(34:36 - 35:23)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Sorry, a bit of a tangent there, but go ahead.

Dave Eng:

Well, I'm going to return to that. But for Isle of Skye, I think what was tough for me here is the fact that you've got to price all those tiles behind your screen, right? And what's even tougher is, if no one buys it, you're stuck. You bought it.

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

So, I think there's less AP in the pricing consideration compared to Castles of Mad King Ludwig, but in this game, I've agonized over, like, do I price it at 12 or 11? Because if someone buys it at 12, that would be terrible, because I really want this tile. But if I buy it at 12, I'm going to be broke.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I know.

Dave Eng:

So, I feel like Isle of Skye is like, you have to thread the needle.

(35:24 - 36:20)

Brian Eng:

Well, that's funny, because I found it the opposite. I found that because of the fixed pricing, and because everybody is looking at the one auction that you're creating, I had more AP in Castles. Whereas I only have three tiles to price...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

...and honestly, you really only have two, because I can pretty easily decide which one I'm destroying.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, yeah. I'm really just pricing two, and I know that other people are pricing, and I have an idea of other people's money.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

And how much money I want to be left with, because I always just considered, okay, worst case for money is I'm going to end up buying both of these tiles.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

So, how much money do I need to be left with? That limits where I can price, and then I go from there, kind of. I felt like you're only pricing two, whereas in Castles you're always pricing, I think it's like five or six rooms for the auction.

(36:21 - 37:05)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

But yeah, it's interesting that you found it the opposite.

Dave Eng:

But for Isle of Skye, though, it was like, I'm kind of looking at it, you know, I'm looking at everyone's board, and I'm like, "Oh, you really like lighthouses over there, huh? Maybe you'd like this lighthouse."

Brian Eng:

Also, you've got to think about the tile orientation, right? Because I don't think you can rotate them as freely in Isle of Skye. It could be a lighthouse that they want, but they may not be able to place it.

Dave Eng:

Right, right, right.

Brian Eng:

So, they won't want to buy it.

Dave Eng:

Regardless, though, I do like Isle of Skye. It's my runner-up. My actual noteworthy is Castles of Mad King Ludwig, only because it's number one on BGG.

Brian Eng:

Oh, it's number one?

(37:06 - 37:51)

Dave Eng:

Yeah, it's number one for the mechanic. So, I was like, that's interesting. I guess a lot of other people really like this game, so I'm going to go with that one, but I'm not the biggest fan of it.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I need to look. I thought that Suburbia was rated higher.

Dave Eng:

No, in the listing for this mechanic, in terms of popularity, I think Castles of Mad King Ludwig is number one.

Brian Eng:

Oh, they don't have... Maybe I don't know everything about how Suburbia works. Does Suburbia not have the auction?

Dave Eng:

Because it doesn't... I used to own it.

Brian Eng:

It doesn't have...? Because I know you've got the big collection with all the different cities, the starter tile thing.

(37:52 - 38:41)

Dave Eng:

Yeah, it was too big of a... I think I sold it to Chris, actually. Not your brother, my Banditos board game nonprofit board member Chris.

Brian Eng:

Oh, they use a Dutch auction in Suburbia.

Dave Eng:

Okay.

Brian Eng:

So, it's not in the running for that. That's why. Because I do think it ranks higher than Castles.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Anyways, interesting. Also, when you were talking about this, two things came up for me. One, I think building a huge castle is awesome. But two, doesn't it take up a huge amount of space? Even if it's just the two of you?

Brian Eng:

Especially when we use a lot more tiles. But I had that big table, that full sheet of plywood that I just use as our table, and it's only the two of us.

(38:42 - 39:59)

Dave Eng:

So, do you use every tile by the end?

Brian Eng:

Not every tile, because you do want to have some... oh, you don't know if this room is going to show up.

Dave Eng:

Oh, I see.

Brian Eng:

But I think the two-player game was something like 30-something rooms.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

I think we went to, like, the maximum player count.

Dave Eng:

Crazy.

Brian Eng:

And then, actually, it's one of the games where the expansion ruined the game a little bit for me.

Dave Eng:

Why is that?

Brian Eng:

So, the first expansion, I don't know if there's multiple, but this expansion that came out, I don't remember what the name of it is, but it added that you could build a moat around the castle.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

But the problem is that, since we weren't playing by the proper number of castle pieces, you couldn't fit your castle into the moat that gets created. So, you had to go back to the official piece count for it to work properly, and then our castles weren't as big anymore, and then it was like, oh, well, the thing I like the most is building this huge castle. And it's weird, because I knew that that expansion existed, and then I couldn't just go back to playing without it.

(40:00 - 40:47)

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Also, when you were telling me about this during the original, like, renaissance, I always mixed it up with Castles of Burgundy, right? Because they're both Castles.

Brian Eng:

Yes. I think people do refer to both of them as just Castles.

Dave Eng:

But yeah, so my most noteworthy was Castles of Mad King Ludwig, only because it's number one. I'm not a fan of the game.

Brian Eng:

I put Isle of Skye as most noteworthy because it was a Kennerspiel winner.

Dave Eng:

Okay. And then that was my runner-up. But I'm thinking about most noteworthy, biggest, from a popularity perspective, right? Not necessarily an award-winning perspective.

Brian Eng:

Right. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, either way, it seems like we had a very similar mix of games in our choices today.

(40:48 - 41:33)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

All right. You have anything else for major examples?

Dave Eng:

No, I think that was it for me. We can move on.

Brian Eng:

All right. Shall we do our roll?

Dave Eng:

Yep.

All right, I have seven.

Brian Eng:

I got ten.

Dave Eng:

Okay. All right. So, Brian, you want to explain to everyone who has not listened before how we run Beyond the Basics?

Brian Eng:

In Beyond the Basics, we basically talk about a few points of what we like the most about the mechanic...

(41:34 - 42:19)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

...and then some of the things we dislike about the mechanic. It's fairly open-form. And this one, kind of particularly, I couldn't find too many dislikes, because I actually like this mechanic a lot.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

So, I just talked about things that could be something that people dislike, or are common dislikes, from when I've talked to other people about games with the I cut, you choose mechanic.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

Okay, so we will start off with some likes, and I will go with my first one. We've touched on some of these points as we talked about the games, but the first thing I like is that it is a unique way to implement self-balancing into a game.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Things like negotiation, I would call self-balancing.

(42:20 - 43:16)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

So, again, just to break it down, the player who's doing the splitting is striving to make the options equal, generally. I think that's the goal, to make it harder for the person choosing and to be less punishing. But what it creates is this almost fluidity in the value of the resources that you're splitting. If you were splitting, I don't know, four gems, two red gems and two blue gems, well, the equal way is, okay, one red gem and one blue gem on one side, one red gem and one blue gem on the other side.

Dave Eng:

Yep.

Brian Eng:

But in a board game, there's different game states. So, if the other player's hoarding red gems, well, that might change the way you want to split those gems. And I think that keeps it fresh. It keeps you engaged. It forces you to analyze the game state and also be able to read your opponent.

(43:17 - 44:10)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm. I think that The Great Split is very good for that, actually, you know.

Brian Eng:

And also part of that is, I think they call it, like, a poison pill.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

It's like, oh, you can make something good, but there's games where there are things you don't want. It's like, okay, this is good for them, but I'm going to put this punishing thing in that group so that if they want it, they're also going to have to take this crappy thing.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, and I like that, because, well, I always like antagonistic...

Brian Eng:

Right. So, that's my first like, the unique ways that it self-balances a game.

Dave Eng:

Right. My first like goes all the way back to the decision structure. I think a lot of the games we've talked about in the past, we're talking about the action, and as a designer, as the auteur of the game...

(44:11 - 45:05)

Brian Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Dave Eng:

...we are often making up what the decision structure is. Well, what I think is cool about I cut, you choose is that we're kind of handing over that decision structure to the player. We're formulating, okay, here are the resources, but part of the game is actually trying to determine what the decision is going to be for your opponents. And I think that's kind of cool, because it is making the players themselves part of that experience. We are still structuring what the game is going to be about, but ultimately, it's going to be up to them. And you can see that in New York Slice, again, the most thematic. So, for me, I don't know if we'll see other mechanics that are kind of like this, but we're kind of making the player a co-author of the entire decision framework experience, and I think that's pretty cool.

(45:06 - 45:53)

Brian Eng:

Yeah, yeah. I mean... sorry, do you have more to say on that?

Dave Eng:

No, no, that was it.

Brian Eng:

Because it kind of leads into my second like a little bit, and that is, it creates a high level of agency and also high levels of engagement in the game, because neither the splitter nor the chooser can really be passive. The splitter has kind of structural control. They control the composition, creating a trap in the split, those kinds of things. And the chooser gets to execute the control, right?

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Because they get the final say. They can ruin the plans of the splitter if they read the situation correctly. So, that keeps that high level of engagement outside of your turn, you know, because you need to understand what the other player wants.

(45:54 - 46:49)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And I like that, because, again, then you're engaged both on your turn and on the opponent's turn.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. So, high engagement throughout. Higher engagement, high agency, right?

Brian Eng:

Right.

Dave Eng:

Okay. That's a good one. My second like is that whatever you're choosing in the game is, again, dependent on the game that we've set up. You know, it's still prone to analysis paralysis, like we talked about with Castles of Mad King Ludwig, right? What I like is games that have I split, you choose but still have an element of hidden information. That's why I think Agent Avenue works really well.

Brian Eng:

Yes. I agree.

Dave Eng:

Because it's, again, two choices, right? You have the face-up choice, and then you have the face-down choice. But if I know you, Brian, I know you're going to be like, "What's in the box? I want the what's in the box," because that could be even better.

(46:50 - 47:53)

Brian Eng:

Yeah, yeah. I think, definitely, a lot of the times I'll rationalize to myself, like, "No, no, this is a double bluff. So, I'm taking the unknown."

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah. So, I like it. And I talked about my Skyward house rule, where instead you make the splits as you draw cards, because it was just taking forever before that. So, my like is splitting, but splitting it in a way where the chooser does not have all of the information.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. And actually, back to The Great Split again...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

It's another one where, I guess in two players, you can pay more attention, because you keep those cards that you had to split, but you get a few more, and some are discarded. So, you know some of the cards that might be there. And I feel like I wouldn't do this with more than two players, but at two players, I can kind of be like, okay, I know he has to split up these kinds of resources. Like, I know there were five art symbols to be split.

(47:54 - 48:41)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

And he's probably not going to put all of them on one side, so I'm going to be getting some art symbols when it comes back. You know, I want to get the art ribbons, or whatever, I don't know the terminology, but the thing that makes the art symbols worth more, because I know that I'm getting art in the back, that kind of thing. And again, it's imperfect information, but you have just enough to kind of be like, okay, I can make some guesses, and possibly get that rush of, like, yes, I guessed correctly.

Dave Eng:

Right.

Brian Eng:

Which is why I like the face-down card in Agent Avenue, because when I guess correctly that they actually hid a good card under there...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

...it feels good, because, you know, they were counting on getting that card.

(48:42 - 49:27)

Dave Eng:

Yeah. So, yeah, I agree.

Brian Eng:

Okay, I'll move on to my third like.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah, go ahead.

Brian Eng:

This one is pretty straightforward. It's an old mechanic. It is simple to understand, and I like that. It's not really luck-based at all.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

It's just very straightforward, easy to explain. Most people just kind of get it right away, because through their childhood, they have experienced I split, you choose.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And I like strong mechanics that are simple but add a lot to the game.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm. Agreed. And I think that not every mechanic we've talked about so far... I'm trying to think about, like, maybe even our first episode, Brian, grid coverage. That's also pretty simple, but I think that's not a decision framework mechanic like I split, you choose, right?

(49:28 - 50:17)

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

So, that was your third like?

Brian Eng:

Third one. Yep.

Dave Eng:

Mine is, once I started thinking about this and just playing other games online, I was thinking about where the splitting and the constraint is in, like, drafting. Or just choosing things, like when you're dividing resources for I split, you choose. I was trying to think about it. Would you say that Azul has I split, you choose? Oh, no, I guess not, because I'm thinking about the factories.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, because whatever you choose goes to you, and what you don't choose goes to the middle, but no one set up the factory, because it's randomly drawn.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah. But I was thinking about that constraint as well, of being able to choose. Like, whatever I'm choosing is whatever I want, but whatever I don't choose is going to be someone else's choice.

(50:18 - 51:18)

Brian Eng:

Yeah. I mean, I wouldn't call it I split, you choose, but it does have a similar feeling of, okay, these other pieces are going to go here, so I do need to think about what is happening with the things I'm not choosing.

Dave Eng:

All right, right, right.

Brian Eng:

Okay. Shall we move on? You have more likes, or...?

Dave Eng:

No, those are my likes.

Brian Eng:

Okay, we'll move on to dislikes. So, the first one we have talked about quite a bit, and it is that it often leads to high analysis paralysis for the splitter.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. And Castles is a big one that I used to deal with a lot. You talked about Isle of Skye having that issue for you. And I think it just comes down to... I mean, both of those are games that can be played with more than two players, which I think just accentuates that there can be an information overload, all the factors in evaluating the value of each of the different things that need to be split.

(51:19 - 52:20)

Dave Eng:

Right.

Brian Eng:

And if you're trying to calculate every permutation of what your opponent might do, it's going to lead you down that path. So, I think that it is easy for it to lead down that path in a lot of games, and the ones that keep it cleaner and avoid that are better able to implement it, where you kind of keep your choices simple, right?

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. And you can still have that same I split, you choose agency feeling without the analysis paralysis.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, I agree. My first dislike is also analysis paralysis.

Brian Eng:

All right. Yeah, I assumed we would both have it.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. I just think it's up to the designer to try to make that decision framework, because, again, I'm interpreting I split, you choose as giving authorship to the players as well, being able to make these decisions, and not as the designer. But you also don't want to make it so that it's just too much information.

(52:21 - 53:09)

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Yep. Okay, so my second one.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

My second dislike is one where, at least in the example I'm going to use, I don't necessarily feel this way, but I have had people tell me they feel this way. It's that in games where there is hidden information, the chooser feels like they're just guessing. And specifically, I was talking to somebody about Agent Avenue.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

And they felt like, when they chose, it was just random. I don't agree, because I think, again, you are reading the game state, you're reading the opponent, but I can understand why you might feel that way, right? And maybe other games feel more random. So, that could be, I guess, a dislike, if you feel that hidden information with I split, you choose makes your choices feel irrelevant.

(53:10 - 54:09)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm. I see. I don't know if I completely agree with that. I guess I would need to see a tactical decision in which that would... I can't think of a game where I agree with that.

Brian Eng:

But specifically, someone I was showing Agent Avenue to, that was their feedback when I asked how they liked the game. They just said that when they're picking, they just pick at random, because they felt like it was just a guess. And I'm like, well, I don't agree.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Not in that game, at least. Yeah, I feel like, well, maybe it's because you may not know what all the cards do immediately.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I do think you need to know which cards are possible to come up.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

But again, there's a tactical decision on what cards you're putting... I guess you could play random. You could just throw any card down, you know? But there's definitely an advantage to setting it up to mitigate the risk for you as the splitter, right?

(54:10 - 55:00)

Dave Eng:

Right. And I think it's balanced quite well with the fact that you just have a four-card hand, so you may not get the good cards that you need to put in the options.

Brian Eng:

In fact, that happens often, where I don't want to use any of these cards to make the decisions, right?

Dave Eng:

Right, right. Which is why they give you the three swaps, right?

Brian Eng:

Yeah, you get a mulligan. But yeah, I think it's actually balanced quite well.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm. What dislike are we on, Brian? So, that was your second?

Brian Eng:

My second dislike, yeah.

Dave Eng:

Okay, so on to my dislike.

Brian Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Dave Eng:

Mine would be the pie rule, because I feel like it is an I split, you choose, I don't doubt that. However, I do criticize games that have it where that's the only time that they do I split, you choose.

(55:01 - 55:53)

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

At the very beginning. Because then I wouldn't... like, we played, what is it, Ponte del Diavolo?

Brian Eng:

Yes. That was the bridge-building one, right?

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Well, when I was looking at it, I was like, oh, this looks pleasant. And then I was reading the description, and it just says it's a brutal area control game. I'm not going to do well at this. We finished one game and I'm like, I don't think I have any really good options left. I'm just going to keep clicking on open areas to place tiles, because I don't think I can really do anything. So, in the beginning, when you placed your opening move, I was like, I don't know if that's a good opening move.

Brian Eng:

I think, with neither of us having played, I was thinking about that first move, and then I'm like, neither of us have played...

(55:54 - 56:46)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

...so I don't know what a good move is. I doubt Dave knows what a significantly good move is either. So, I'm just going to randomly place some pieces down.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, you can just place it wherever.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, and so I didn't think it mattered in that sense, but I did get that sense, because I made one or two early mistakes...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

...until I picked up how I should be playing. And then I think you took a little bit longer to catch on, because I had already kind of set it up where I was chaining my bridges, and then I feel like there wasn't a real easy way for you to come back from that.

Dave Eng:

There's the constraint, right, Bri, with the islands. You needed at least four tiles to form an island, but they also can't be adjacent to each other.

(56:47 - 57:38)

Brian Eng:

Right, right. Yep. The restriction of placing pieces around the island only comes into effect once the island has been created. So, if you've only placed three pieces of the island, I can place pieces in a way that stops you from completing the island.

Dave Eng:

That's the blocking aspect.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, and that's the blocking aspect, which, again, once I was a little ahead of you, I made it so that basically you couldn't stop the bridges I was going to build, and I also blocked you from completing, I think, some of your early islands.

Dave Eng:

Oh, I see. Okay.

Brian Eng:

It created a significant deficit in the beginning for you, and I don't know the game well enough to know how easy it is to come back from that.

Dave Eng:

I mean, based on what I read about it, I don't think there is a way to come back. It's like, once you get blocked, right?

(57:39 - 58:42)

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

Right. I was watching that.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, because if you don't count out your spaces, you're not going to have enough room to finish either island. Okay, maybe you could build the bridge or whatever, but if you don't finish the island, it doesn't count.

Dave Eng:

All right. Yeah, so you've got to make sure.

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

So, yeah, it is pretty brutal for me here.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. I think that's one where you've got to play a few and be on relatively equal footing with your opponent...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

...or it's not going to be very fun.

Dave Eng:

All right. Are we on our third dislike now, Bri?

Brian Eng:

Yeah, on our third. So, my third dislike comes down to, kind of, if a player is not that engaged. And again, it's not necessarily a dislike of the mechanic itself, but if a player creates a bad split, and I think this is more apparent in games with three or more players, if there's a bad split where the player didn't see something that one of the players could get, it can give a significant advantage to one player, almost to the point of, like, kingmaking.

(58:43 - 59:31)

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Oh, I see.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. So, if they're just like, you know, you get to four players, like, okay, I'm only going to worry about myself...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

...and what I need, and you just give the next player a huge deal, and they get way ahead because of that, that can kind of suck, right? And again, I couldn't think of that in... I mean, if you make a mistake in a two-player game, well, obviously it's the other person who's going to take that advantage. I'm more talking about three or more players, like in Isle of Skye.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, yeah. Or Castles.

Brian Eng:

I don't really know how to address that, other than I think that players just...

Dave Eng:

That's right. I don't know if it's the mechanic. It's if a player is not paying enough attention.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Or doesn't see the game state, right? It's not really an issue with the mechanic.

(59:32 - 1:00:43)

Dave Eng:

All right. That was your third dislike, right?

Brian Eng:

That's my third. Yeah.

Dave Eng:

Okay. My third one is, I was talking about this before with Ponte del Diavolo, because the pie rule is the only I split, you choose, and it's at the very beginning, for the setup. Another game that got listed on BGG with this mechanic was Hanamikoji, which we played a bunch of times, right? And it's listed there because of two of the actions that you can choose. One is called Gift, and Competition is the other I split, you choose. Gift is three cards: your opponent chooses one card, and you get the other two. And in Competition, you take four cards and you split them into two piles, and then your opponent takes one, and you take the other pile.

So, now I'm trying to think about it, because, you know, many games have multiple mechanics. Hanamikoji has an I split, you choose mechanic in the game as part of other mechanics. So, then I don't know if I'm being too elitist in saying, like, yeah, it has some I split, you choose, but only in these two circumstances. So, I specifically did not put it in any of my major examples because of that. Because it is not the main mechanic, I don't consider it an I split, you choose game.

(1:00:44 - 1:01:34)

Brian Eng:

Okay. Yeah. Now, that being said, I also wouldn't call Hex an I split, you choose game. Same thing that you said, with the pie rule being the only time that it uses I split, you choose. I just couldn't come up with anything specific for early games.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, which is why Castles might be my first one. My actual one.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

But I figured it was a broad enough and common enough rule that I just used that space to talk about it.

Dave Eng:

Right, right. So, I don't know if it's a nomenclature thing, or if I'm just being a board game elitist, but that's how I feel, you know? Hanamikoji is often used as an example of I split, you choose, right?

Brian Eng:

I do think one unique thing they do is the Gift one, where there's three cards and the player chooses one. It's interesting, because when you initiate that, you're actually forcing the other player to be the splitter.

(1:01:35 - 1:02:26)

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm. Oh, yeah. You're setting up the structure.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. You're setting up the option, I suppose. One of them is you create the options, and the other one is you're forcing the other player to create the option, which is interesting. It's different.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. And I mean, there's only four different things you do in that game, so half of them are I split, you choose.

Brian Eng:

So, yeah, it actually uses it more than the pie rule, right?

Dave Eng:

Right.

Brian Eng:

So, I do think it is a legitimate example, but in my head, I agree with you, I don't call it an I split, you choose game.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, I agree.

Brian Eng:

And I haven't played, I guess, the evolution of that, which is Geisha's Road. I Kickstarted it, and it's still sitting in shrink.

Dave Eng:

Oh, no. You've got to open it.

Brian Eng:

No, I open things right away, but I haven't played it. I've heard it's good, but Hanamikoji was just so clean.

(1:02:27 - 1:03:12)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, that's why... it did come with a bunch more powers. So, there's the four powers you get, and I think it came with, like, eight different sets of four powers.

Dave Eng:

Uh-huh.

Brian Eng:

So, you can definitely switch up the game, and also keep it very simple with what it came with.

Dave Eng:

I call that the Queendomino effect, because I got Queendomino because I really like Kingdomino, and Kingdomino is a very clean design.

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

Queendomino mucked it all up. I do like Queendomino, but I agree with you, it's no longer the simple, almost gateway game that Kingdomino is.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, exactly.

Dave Eng:

I did get Moon River, though, which I feel like is the proper successor to Kingdomino.

Brian Eng:

Okay, I haven't played that one.

(1:03:13 - 1:04:06)

Dave Eng:

That one is essentially like Kingdomino, but it's Western-themed, and there's more interesting powers, I would say.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Yeah, I felt that way about Kingdomino too, because Kingdomino also had a bunch of expansions, I think, like Giants, and...

Dave Eng:

Yeah, I never picked up...

Brian Eng:

Exactly. And I was just like, each time, it almost took it away from what kind of made it...

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

...appealing.

Dave Eng:

Yeah, its clean simplicity.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. I didn't get the Giants one. I got Queendomino, and I think you're able to combine Kingdomino and Queendomino if you wanted, something like that. I never got around to doing it.

Dave Eng:

I traded away my Queendomino.

Brian Eng:

I do have one more dislike, actually.

Dave Eng:

Okay.

Brian Eng:

And again, I don't necessarily share it, but I think other people may feel this way sometimes, in that the outcome of I split, you choose always feels bad to some people, for both people.

(1:04:07 - 1:04:53)

Dave Eng:

Oh, the splitter and the chooser?

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Because the splitter always gets their second choice...

Dave Eng:

Not always.

Brian Eng:

...and the chooser has that feeling that the best choice is a trap. So, there's always that thought in their mind that they either split it wrong or they chose incorrectly. As opposed to, there are games where whatever choice you make, you feel like you got rewarded.

Dave Eng:

Yep.

Brian Eng:

And I feel that some people could feel the opposite about I split, you choose.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

Whatever I did, I could have done something better. So, that could be seen as a dislike. But yeah, that was my... I just had a fourth one I squeezed in there at the last minute.

Dave Eng:

All right. Is that good? Are we all good for Beyond the Basics?

(1:04:54 - 1:05:49)

Brian Eng:

I think that's it for Beyond the Basics. Now it's really just any other talking points. Did you have anything else you wanted to bring up?

Dave Eng:

Yeah, I actually had some philosophical questions for you, Brian.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

For the bonus round. Before I go into this, did you have stuff for the bonus round too, just so we know?

Brian Eng:

I have a few things. We'll see if they come up, but you can go ahead first.

Dave Eng:

Okay. So, I was trying to break this down, to determine if a game falls into I split, you choose. I had three and a half tests for the game, and I want to read them to you and get your opinion. So, test number one is, is there an actual division into distinct options? If it doesn't have that, then it's not an I split, you choose. There has to be a division of options. Those options can be resources, turns, or anything else.

(1:05:50 - 1:06:47)

Brian Eng:

Right. So, sorry, we're going to go strict I split, you choose?

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Which, in my mind, then, forget about "I price, you buy"? Like, two-player games only?

Dave Eng:

No, I mean, for me, I guess I have these three things in order for it to be... okay, I split, you... sorry, it's the division into options.

Brian Eng:

Yes. Yes. It definitely has to have that.

Dave Eng:

Okay. Number two: does someone other than the divider pick first?

Brian Eng:

Yes.

Dave Eng:

Yep. And then test number three, point one... I'll call it 3a: does the divider have to live with what's left?

Brian Eng:

Yes.

Dave Eng:

Okay. And then here's my 3b, because I found a game that does not follow it that I would consider I split, you choose: is the self-binding constraint what makes the divider play fair? Going back to what you opened with, Brian, about you and Chris splitting the fruit. That constraint of, I really have to make this a fair split, because I could get the worst option.

(1:06:48 - 1:07:37)

Brian Eng:

Well, they have to watch what they incentivize. They don't necessarily have to make it fair. But if they're trying to make the chooser pick a certain one, they have to make it appear like the one they want to choose. And if that isn't the goal, if it's just balancing, well, they want to be happy with either one.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

They want it to be as equal as possible in the valuation of the chooser, right?

Dave Eng:

Right, right, right.

Brian Eng:

And that's where I talked about how the psychological value has to be equal, even if the on-paper value is not.

Dave Eng:

The on-paper value. Okay. So, I want to go into these in detail. Did you have insights on any of the tests I brought up so far?

Brian Eng:

No, I mean, it kind of follows. It's a more detailed version of our definition, right?

(1:07:38 - 1:08:29)

Dave Eng:

Right, right.

Brian Eng:

Just breaking it down into the components of the definition.

Dave Eng:

So, I want to challenge test 3a, because the game I played yesterday in prep for this recording is a new release called Honeypot. I think I talked about it in our pre-production meeting. In Honeypot, it's considered an I split, you choose, and I would agree with this. However, it also has an element of push your luck in it. The way you play Honeypot is, there are a bunch of cards, and those cards provide scoring opportunities. You're going to take an envelope, you're going to take six cards, and you're going to put them all face down in the envelope, and that's what you're going to pass to an opponent, kind of like The Great Split. And then your opponent is going to reveal two cards at the same time, the top two cards.

(1:08:30 - 1:09:57)

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

And their options are, they can take those two cards, or they can discard them and reveal the next two cards.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

And if they don't want that, then they have to discard it and take the last two cards.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

So, you're splitting them. However...

Brian Eng:

So, these are the cards out of the envelope?

Dave Eng:

These are the cards out of the envelope.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Are the cards placed into the envelope in a specific order?

Dave Eng:

Yes, you get to choose the order.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, right. So, the order that those pairs are revealed in is chosen?

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

It's purposeful.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Okay, okay.

Dave Eng:

So, what I think makes this unique is, one, it combines I split, you choose with push your luck. And then two, if, say, the opponent you pass it to chooses the first two cards, leaving the last four, opponents after them can use a swipe token to take over the choosing position. They can spend that token to go through the envelope, and then they get to decide whether or not they want those next two cards. And then, if there's still cards left over, another person to the left of that chooser can use their swipe token to choose the last two cards. However, what I think is unique here, compared to the games we talked about, is that as the divider, I never have the option to choose the cards in the envelope. I only make a choice for other players. It never comes back to the person dividing.

(1:09:58 - 1:10:55)

Brian Eng:

Correct?

Dave Eng:

It's in the rules. Yeah. Even if they don't use the swipe token, right, if they pass, you can never take it. It's just trash.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, okay. Is this game three-player-plus only?

Dave Eng:

No, the two-player variant is pure I split, you choose. Instead of the envelope, you just make lots, and then your opponent chooses one and you get the other.

Brian Eng:

So, then, in that case, the splitter does get the stuff that they've made into the...

Dave Eng:

Yeah, that's part of the variant. But we only played it with five players yesterday.

Brian Eng:

So, again, I think that because the strict I split, you choose is really for two players, then it still works, and you're still trying... I don't know. I mean, it depends on how the scoring works in the game, whether you care that they're equal. But when you create the six cards, is it just that you draw six cards and you have to make three groups with those six, right?

(1:10:56 - 1:11:43)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I'm not sure how the strategy goes beyond making them equal. I guess, as far as the first person to choose, you can kind of game it psychologically, whether you want them to take those first two, or you want them to keep pushing their luck and take the last two and end up getting screwed, that kind of thing.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

But if there's this other opportunity where the other people may or may not swipe, it's hard to then strategize for that, right?

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Yeah, because the game also has some adjacency scoring. I had a card that allowed me to score cards for my opponents on my left and right, so at that point, I'm incentivized to give my opponent more of those cards, because they will benefit, but I will also benefit. But after that...

(1:11:44 - 1:12:30)

Brian Eng:

Yeah, right. That's true. Because an opponent across the table from you really has nothing to do with you, scoring-wise.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

I guess I would say that I would still call it I split, you choose, but it does significantly change the way that the splitter is thinking about it, right? Because nothing is coming back to them and impacting them directly. Also, it's very specific that they're just getting these random six cards split. And again, it doesn't come back to them, so you're really just splitting it for the other person. And it's a split of, they're going to get one of these, and how to try to make them get... I'm not even sure how you would try to make them get one pair specifically. I think I'd have to play the game.

(1:12:31 - 1:13:41)

Dave Eng:

Yeah. I mean, like you said, there's a bunch of poison pill cards too. And when people reveal, they're like, "I don't like this choice. I'm going to go to the next one," and the next one is just two poison pills.

Brian Eng:

That's definitely one thing I could see. Yeah, it's hard for me to say exactly without playing the game, but I think I would still call it I split, you choose, though.

Dave Eng:

It's fun. I think you should play.

Brian Eng:

Yeah. No, I'll be there soon.

Dave Eng:

I had two specific games to talk about that were edge cases, Bri. But I'll turn it over to you first, because you said you had stuff for the bonus round.

Brian Eng:

Mine was, again, kind of more of an analysis. I was trying to think: do you think that there is any inherent advantage to being either the splitter or the chooser? And the way I was trying to determine that was, if we played a game of Agent Avenue, but one person always split and the other person always chose, do you think it'd be more likely for the splitter to win or the chooser to win? You know, because we talked about it being self-balancing.

(1:13:42 - 1:14:35)

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Then, in theory, my immediate thought is that it shouldn't matter if you're the splitter or the chooser.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Right? If it's balancing itself.

Dave Eng:

That's a good philosophical question. I would like to see it in practice, because, I mean, I guess outside of the skill of how good of a splitter...

Brian Eng:

Yeah. Yeah, if you call that a skill.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. Well, so Agent Avenue, again, is not perfect information.

Brian Eng:

It's not perfect information.

Dave Eng:

So, then, is informational advantage better than first mover advantage?

Brian Eng:

I guess that becomes the question, then. Yeah, I don't know.

Dave Eng:

I don't know if I can actively rule on that without trying it.

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

If we play a game of Agent Avenue and one of us is just the splitter...

Brian Eng:

I would like to see how that... yeah, I'm just curious. But to have any sort of statistical merit, we'd have to play, like, a hundred games.

(1:14:36 - 1:15:22)

Dave Eng:

Yeah. And with more than just us.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, that's right. But that actually came into my head last night. I was just like, what if one person just always split? No, it should be fair. If it's balanced, it should still be fair. It may not be fun, but from a balance standpoint...

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

Which do you prefer?

Dave Eng:

I... I prefer to be...

Brian Eng:

You prefer to be the splitter?

Dave Eng:

Yeah, I think I like to be the splitter. Yeah, I like to set the trap. I did that in Honeypot, dumping two poison pill cards at the very bottom of the pile. Like, someone's going to swipe these, and they're going to get it for sure.

Brian Eng:

Yeah.

Dave Eng:

You had another bonus round item?

Brian Eng:

No, I think that's all I had to talk about. You've got more stuff?

(1:15:23 - 1:16:17)

Dave Eng:

Okay. So, yeah, I had two games I was trying to consider, because I felt these were on the cusp, and I think you could make the argument for them.

Brian Eng:

Okay.

Dave Eng:

One of them, when I was thinking about this, was a shower thought. You played Captain Flip?

Brian Eng:

Yes. Yes.

Dave Eng:

So, for those who haven't played it, I guess you'd call it a push your luck game, because whoever is the active player pulls a tile from the bag, and then they hold that tile in one orientation, and they can either take that tile or flip it to the other side. All you know is that the action on the other side of the tile is different from the front, right? So, I was thinking, is that I cut, you choose? And I came to the decision that it is not, because in order for it to be that, another player has to make the split.

(1:16:18 - 1:17:20)

Brian Eng:

Has to make the split. Yeah. Here, randomness is making the split.

Dave Eng:

Yeah. In this case, it's the designer that made the split, right? There's nothing based on the game state deciding the split.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, right. Which is what the opponent would do, right?

Dave Eng:

Right. Here, it's just whatever is printed on the tile.

Brian Eng:

Yeah, I think, again, that's more push your luck.

Dave Eng:

And then the other game I had... I think we talked about this in the pilot episode, actually, for grid coverage. It's Tiny Towns. Tiny Towns is the game where whoever is the chooser chooses a resource, and then it's like... we call it the bingo mechanic. I think we didn't cover that yet. But you choose the resource, like wood or stone or clay, whatever, and then everyone else takes that resource and places it on their board, and if you can make a specific pattern, then you get to build your building. So, I don't think this is I cut, you choose, because you are just choosing a specific resource, but you're not dividing anything. You are just...

(1:17:21 - 1:18:06)

Brian Eng:

But I would... sorry, finish your thought.

Dave Eng:

No, I don't think you're dividing anything. You're just choosing a resource, and everyone gets that resource, you know, whether they want it or not. It could be beneficial to you, but you're not splitting anything.

Brian Eng:

I would say it's more analogous to Puerto Rico's follow mechanic.

Dave Eng:

Yes.

Brian Eng:

Where, instead of an action, you're choosing a resource, and everyone else is also doing that.

Dave Eng:

Yeah.

Brian Eng:

In Puerto Rico, you choose an action, and everyone else gets a lesser version of that action.

Dave Eng:

Mm-hmm.

Brian Eng:

I think it's more akin to that.

Dave Eng:

Okay. Yeah, that's what I decided as well. I think it is a follow mechanic. It is not an... yeah. Those are my two outliers from my shower thoughts that could fall under this mechanic.

(1:18:07 - 1:18:39)

Brian Eng:

Well, I guess that wraps up our I split, you choose episode of AP Table Talk. If you'd like to hear more content like this, please be sure to subscribe. You can also check out more of our content, projects, and other information about us at universityxp.com.

Dave Eng:

Thanks for joining us. We'd also love it if you took some time to rate the show. We live to lift others with learning. So, if you found this episode useful, consider sharing it with someone who could also benefit. Until next time, game on.

References

Alexander Pfister. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamedesigner/11767/alexander-pfister

Allers, J. D. (2008). Piece o' Cake. Rio Grande Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/37371/piece-o-cake

Allers, J. D. (2017). New York Slice. Bézier Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/208895/new-york-slice

Alspach, T. (2012). Suburbia. Bézier Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/123260/suburbia

Alspach, T. (2014). Castles of Mad King Ludwig. Bézier Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/155426/castles-of-mad-king-ludwig

Auction / bidding. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamemechanic/2012/auction-bidding

Auction: Dutch. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamemechanic/2924/auction-dutch

Bluffing. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamecategory/1023/bluffing

Cathala, B. (2016). Kingdomino. Blue Orange Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/204583/kingdomino

Cathala, B. (2017). Queendomino. Blue Orange Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/232043/queendomino

Cathala, B. (2018). Kingdomino: Age of Giants. Blue Orange Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgameexpansion/240909/kingdomino-age-of-giants

Cathala, B., & Servais, Y. (2023). Moon River. Blue Orange Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/378001/moon-river

Chen, J. Z. (2026). Honeypot. Alderac Entertainment Group. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/458391/honeypot

Chess. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/171/chess

Ebel, M. (2007). Ponte del Diavolo. Hans im Glück. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/27172/ponte-del-diavolo

Eng, D. (2019, September 26). Game Theme. University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2019/9/26/game-theme

Eng, D. (2020, February 20). Game components. University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2020/2/20/game-components

Eng, D. (2020, August 20). What is player agency? University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2020/8/20/what-is-player-agency

Eng, D. (2020, December 3). Game Mechanics for Learning. University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2020/12/3/game-mechanics-for-learning

Eng, D. (2021, July 6). What is Kingmaking? University XP. Retrieved October 13, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2021/7/6/what-is-kingmaking

Eng, D. (2021, July 27). How to Teach Someone to Play a Game. University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2021/7/27/how-to-teach-someone-to-play-a-game

Eng, D. (2022, March 29). What is Game Balance? University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2022/3/29/what-is-game-balance

Eng, D. (2022, September 27). What is strategy in gameplay? University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2022/9/27/what-is-strategy-in-gameplay

Eng, D. (2022, October 25). What is Analysis Paralysis? University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2022/10/25/what-is-analysis-paralysis

Eng, D. (2023, April 11). What are tactics? University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2023/4/11/what-are-tactics

Eng, D. (2023, December 5). What is the Game State? University XP. Retrieved October 1, 2026, from https://www.universityxp.com/blog/2023/12/5/what-is-the-game-state

Eng, D., & Eng, B. (Hosts). (2023, June 4). AP table talk: Grid coverage (No. 87) [Audio podcast episode]. In Experience points. University XP. https://www.universityxp.com/podcast/87

Eng, D., & Eng, B. (Hosts). (2024, July 14). AP table talk: Trick taking, ladder climbing (No. 116) [Audio podcast episode]. In Experience points. University XP. https://www.universityxp.com/podcast/116

Eng, D., & Eng, B. (Hosts). (2024, November 10). AP table talk: Deck, bag, and pool building (No. 124) [Audio podcast episode]. In Experience points. University XP. https://www.universityxp.com/podcast/124

Eng, D., & Eng, B. (Hosts). (2024, December 15). AP table talk: Follow (No. 127) [Audio podcast episode]. In Experience points. University XP. https://www.universityxp.com/podcast/127

Engelstein, G., & Shalev, I. (2022). Building blocks of tabletop game design: An encyclopedia of mechanisms (2nd ed.). CRC Press. https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/9781032015811

Evans, B. (2017). Skyward. Rule & Make. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/209664/skyward

Feld, S. (2011). The Castles of Burgundy. alea. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/84876/castles-burgundy

Go. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/188/go

Hach, H., & Silva, L. (2022). The Great Split. Horrible Guild. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/366752/the-great-split

Hex. (n.d.). Board Game Arena. https://boardgamearena.com/gamepanel?game=hex

I cut, you choose. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamemechanic/2906/i-cut-you-choose

Kiesling, M. (2017). Azul. Next Move Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/230802/azul

Kudahl, C., & Kudahl, L. (2024). Agent Avenue. Nerdlab Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/422732/agent-avenue

Lin, E., & Chiang, J. (2021). Hanamikoji: Geisha's Road. EmperorS4. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/322339/hanamikoji-geishas-road

McPherson, P. (2019). Tiny Towns. Alderac Entertainment Group. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/265736/tiny-towns

Meleshin, O., & Yamshchikov, Y. (2023). Pacific Ocean. Timashov Publishing. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/386216/pacific-ocean

Mori, P., & Droit, A. (2024). Captain Flip. Play Punk. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/393325/captain-flip

Nakayama, K. (2013). Hanamikoji. EmperorS4. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/158600/hanamikoji

Pauchon, S. (2009). Jaipur. GameWorks. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/54043/jaipur

Pelikan, A., & Pfister, A. (2015). Isle of Skye: From Chieftain to King. Lookout Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/176494/isle-skye-chieftain-king

Pfister, A. (2014). Port Royal. Pegasus Spiele. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/156009/port-royal

Pfister, A. (2015). Mombasa. eggertspiele. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/172386/mombasa

Pfister, A. (2015). Oh My Goods! Lookout Games. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/183840/oh-my-goods

Pfister, A. (2016). Great Western Trail. eggertspiele. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/193738/great-western-trail

Pfister, A. (2019). Maracaibo. Game's Up. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/276025/maracaibo

Pfister, A., Hendrickson, R., & Bienert, R. (2023). Pirates of Maracaibo. Game's Up. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/397385/pirates-of-maracaibo

Push your luck. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamemechanic/2661/push-your-luck

Schlesser, L. (2022, September 1). New York Slice designer & publisher interview. Bézier Games. https://beziergames.com/blogs/news/new-york-slice-designer-publisher-interview

Set collection. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamemechanic/2004/set-collection

Seyfarth, A. (2002). Puerto Rico. alea. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/3076/puerto-rico

Teuber, K. (1995). Catan. KOSMOS. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/13/catan

Tile placement. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamemechanic/2002/tile-placement

Worker placement. (n.d.). BoardGameGeek. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamemechanic/2082/worker-placement

Wrede, K.-J. (2000). Carcassonne. Hans im Glück. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/822/carcassonne

Cite this Episode:

Eng, D. & Eng, B. (Hosts). (2026, November 15). AP Table Talk: I Cut, You Choose. (No. [177]) [Audio podcast episode]. Experience Points. University XP. https://www.universityxp.com/podcast/177

Internal Ref: UXPK101F3RG1